Alberta’s government has officially applied to the federal court to challenge the legality of a recent federal exemption from the carbon tax for heating oil.
The federal government introduced the exemption in 2023, and Alberta says it applies predominantly to Atlantic Canada and Quebec provinces. Alberta’s application argues that this exemption is unconstitutional, as it disrupts Canada's uniform application of the federal carbon tax.
According to Alberta officials, the federal government initially framed the carbon tax as a universal tool for reducing greenhouse gas emissions across all provinces and territories.
The province said it would argue that argues that the federal government is creating a 'double standard' favouring certain provinces by exempting heating oil. Alberta claims this exemption undermines the federal Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act’s goal of establishing a consistent national framework for carbon pricing, which the Supreme Court of Canada upheld as constitutional in 2021.
Premier Danielle Smith issued a statement highlighting Alberta’s concerns, noting that the exemption creates regional disparities.
"Ottawa decided Canadians in the East deserved a three-year break from paying the carbon tax on their home heating costs," Smith said. "While we’re happy for these Canadians, Alberta, Saskatchewan, and other provinces who heat their homes with natural gas have been deliberately excluded from these savings."
Smith emphasized that Alberta would sue the federal government to address what the province views as unfair treatment under the current carbon pricing rules.
Provincial opposition and economic concerns
Alberta’s Minister of Justice and Attorney General, Mickey Amery, echoed these sentiments, stating that Alberta’s court challenge is an effort to hold the federal government accountable to its legislation. Amery claimed that the Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act does not grant the federal government the authority to apply carbon pricing exemptions selectively to specific regions.
"This exemption is not only unfair to the vast majority of Canadians, but it is also unlawful as the federal government does not have the authority to make special exemptions for certain parts of the country," Amery stated.
Alberta’s government shared economic data projecting that in 2030, the federal carbon tax could cost Canadians approximately $25 billion per year. The province also cited estimates from the Bank of Canada, which suggest that the carbon tax increases inflation by 0.15 per cent year-over-year, contributing to overall cost-of-living pressures. Alberta’s challenge asserts that the exemption benefits a minority of Canadians while excluding others facing similar rising costs.
Since April 1, 2024, Albertans have been paying approximately 35 cents in federal taxes on each litre of fuel, including the carbon tax, federal excise tax, and GST. With fuel costs and home heating being critical concerns in Alberta’s colder climate, the provincial government argues that any disparity in carbon tax policy will disproportionately affect Albertans compared to those who benefit from the heating oil exemption.
Disparities in heating oil usage across Canada
According to provincial officers, heating oil is used primarily in Atlantic Canada and parts of Quebec, where residents rely on it as a primary heat source. According to recent government data, the highest proportion of households using heating oil is found in Prince Edward Island (40 per cent), followed by Nova Scotia (32 per cent) and Newfoundland and Labrador (18 per cent). In comparison, provinces like Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba have less than one per cent of households relying on heating oil, with natural gas being the dominant heating source.
The Alberta government contends that this exemption, while beneficial to Atlantic Canadians and Quebec residents, leaves Albertans without comparable relief. The province claims the carbon tax adds significant costs to its already high winter heating expenses, and without similar measures, Albertans are unfairly disadvantaged.
Legal context and next steps
The federal court application, filed on October 29, seeks judicial review of the heating oil exemption’s constitutionality and requests a court declaration that the exemption is unlawful. Alberta’s argument focuses on the claim that the exemption does not align with the original intent of the Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act, which was to establish a consistent national standard for carbon pricing aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions across Canada.
Alberta’s government is seeking a court order requiring the federal government to apply the carbon tax uniformly or grant comparable exemptions to other provinces.
The legal proceedings come after the federal government rejected multiple requests from Alberta and other provinces to extend similar tax relief for alternative heating sources, such as natural gas. The federal government has argued that the heating oil exemption was necessary to address specific affordability issues in certain regions. However, Alberta’s position is that such regional exceptions undermine the goal of national carbon pricing and create economic imbalances.
In the meantime, Alberta’s government has committed to continuing its efforts to mitigate the impact of the federal carbon tax on its residents. The province has previously implemented measures to reduce fuel and utility costs for Albertans, including various subsidies and rebates to ease the financial impact of energy-related expenses. As Alberta moves forward with its legal challenge, the case's outcome could set a precedent for future federal policies involving regional exemptions.
Last November, the federal government announced that registered distributors can deliver heating oil exempt from the federal fuel charge if used solely to heat homes or buildings but not for industrial processes. According to the government, the upfront exemption doesn’t require a certificate and will remain in effect until March 31, 2027, after which the fuel charge will resume.
The federal government has also underlined that its carbon pricing system returns more money to most households than they pay in costs, with lower-income households benefiting the most.
For 2024-25, the Canada Carbon Rebate offsets household carbon costs, with higher rebates provided in provinces with higher fossil fuel usage. The average household net benefit ranges from $723 in Alberta to $157 in Nova Scotia. Annually, Albertans see $1,056 in terms of the average cost impact per household of the federal system, while the average Canada Carbon Rebate per household is an estimated $1,779.
Sign up to get the latest local news headlines delivered directly to your inbox every afternoon.
Send your news tips, story ideas, pictures, and videos to news@centralalbertaonline.com.
CentralAlbertaOnline encourages you to get your news directly from your trusted source by bookmarking this page and downloading the CentralAlbertaOnline app.